In general, personal injury settlements in New Mexico are not taxable as long as they compensate a person for physical injury or illness. However, funds allocated for punitive damages, interest, emotional distress without physical injury or medical expenses that were deducted in a prior tax year may be subject to taxation under the Internal Revenue Code. Our Albuquerque personal injury attorneys hear this question often, because the answer depends on what each part of the payment is for.
Most Personal Injury Settlements Are Not Taxed
According to Internal Revenue Code Section 104, compensation collected for physical injuries, sickness and disability is not included as part of a person’s gross income for tax purposes. These settlements are tax-free.
Personal injury settlements are generally not taxable because the goal of this compensation is to make an injured party “whole” again. Therefore, the bulk of this type of payout is exempt from federal and state income taxes. Workers’ compensation settlements are also excluded from taxation.
Non-taxable portions of settlement money in New Mexico include payment for present and future medical bills, property damage, and pain and suffering connected to a physical injury. Compensation awarded for lost wages or earnings will be taxed at the same rate as regular income.
What Portions of a Settlement Are Taxable in New Mexico?
Most of a personal injury settlement is not subject to taxation, but certain parts may be taxed as income. Portions of a settlement allocated for the following will be taxed under federal law:
- Punitive damages: compensation awarded to punish a defendant for especially wrongful or negligent acts. In New Mexico, punitive damages can be awarded for reckless or intentional acts.
- Interest: any interest accumulated on an unpaid settlement or judgment award from the time the agreement is made to the time it is paid in full by the defendant.
- Emotional distress alone: a settlement awarded for emotional distress or “pain and suffering” not connected to a bodily injury or physical illness.
- Previously deducted medical costs: any compensation awarded for medical expenses or hospital bills that were previously deducted in another tax year.
The rules regarding which portions of a settlement will get taxed and which are excluded are not always black-and-white. There are exceptions in unique circumstances. It is important to understand exactly how the IRS will tax your specific settlement so that you can be prepared.
How to Organize Your Settlement to Prevent Over-Taxation
Suppose you are given a settlement or judgment award for a personal injury claim in New Mexico; most if not all your monetary recovery will be tax-exempt. However, you may have tax obligations on some parts of your settlement. It’s important to work with an experienced personal injury lawyer at Fine Law Firm to correctly organize and structure your settlement to prevent over-taxation.
A lawyer can break down which parts of your settlement are taxable and which are tax-free. Your lawyer will clearly separate each portion to limit tax exposure. An attorney may also recommend a structured settlement rather than a lump sum to avoid pushing your income into a higher tax bracket.
A lawyer will understand current tax laws and how to protect as much of your settlement or judgment as possible from taxation. Before signing any liability release forms, contact an attorney for a free consultation about your specific circumstance.
How Does the IRS Decide What a Settlement Payment Is For?
The IRS generally looks at what the payment replaces. Money paid for a broken leg is treated as compensation for a physical injury, while money paid to punish the defendant is treated as punishment, regardless of how the injury happened. This is why the wording of your settlement agreement matters. When a release lists one lump sum with no breakdown, the IRS may later look at the underlying claim to decide how to treat the money. Defendants and insurers sometimes prefer vague release language because it keeps negotiations short, but vague language can leave you guessing at tax time. A clear written allocation, drafted before you sign, gives you and your tax preparer something firm to rely on.
Examples of Taxable and Non-Taxable Settlement Parts
Consider a hypothetical Albuquerque crash. A driver with fractures receives $200,000, made up of $70,000 in medical bills, $30,000 in property damage and $100,000 in pain and suffering tied to the fractures. Those amounts fall in the non-taxable categories above. If the case went to judgment and the defendant later paid $4,000 in interest, that $4,000 would be taxable.
Fault is a separate issue. New Mexico follows pure comparative fault, so a finding that you were 20 percent responsible lowers the total you collect, but it does not change whether each remaining dollar is taxable.
Now take a second hypothetical: a worker wins $50,000 for emotional distress from harassment with no physical injury. That amount is generally taxable, although the part that reimburses therapy costs generally is not.
Step-by-Step: Protecting Your Settlement From Surprise Taxes
- Keep records of every expense and loss, so each dollar can be tied to a type of damage.
- Ask that the settlement agreement state how the money is divided among medical costs, property damage, pain and suffering, and any punitive or interest amounts.
- Review the personal injury settlement agreement and release with your attorney before signing, since the terms are hard to change afterward.
- Understand how settlements are paid out, whether as a lump sum or over time, because the payment method can affect taxes.
- Share the final agreement with a tax professional, and read IRS Publication 525 on taxable and nontaxable income before you file.
Why Choose Fine Law Firm
Fine Law Firm has more than 50 years of experience helping injured people in Albuquerque, Las Cruces and across New Mexico. We offer free consultations, so you can ask how a settlement may be taxed before you agree to anything. We work alongside your tax preparer to make sure the settlement is structured and worded with taxes in mind.
Talk to Fine Law Firm About Your Settlement
Questions about a settlement offer are easier to answer before you sign than after. Call Fine Law Firm at (505) 889-3463 to schedule your free consultation.