Fine Law Firm
Fine Law Firm
  • Home
  • About the Firm
    • Firm Overview
    • Meet Our Attorneys
    • Common Questions & Answers
    • Blog
    • Videos
  • Practice Areas
    • Vehicle Accidents
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Premises Liability
    • Product Liability
    • Workplace Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
    • View All+
  • Locations
    • Alamogordo
    • Carlsbad
    • Clovis
    • Farmington
    • Gallup
    • Hobbs
    • Las Cruces
    • Rio Rancho
    • Roswell
    • Santa Fe
  • Results
    • Case Results
    • Testimonials
  • Compare Our Fees
  • Contact Us
24/7 AvailabilityFree Consultation Hablamos Español
Contact Us Hablamos español (505) 889-3463

At Fine Law Firm,
Your Case is Personal

Free Consultation

New Mexico Supreme Court Finds That Lack of Foreseeability Does Not Prevent a Premises Liability Claim from Going to Trial

Free Consultation
May 20, 2014 | Posted in Firm News, New Mexico Laws, Personal Injury Verdicts

The New Mexico Supreme Court recently handed down a decision that may significantly impact the ability of plaintiffs who are injured on another’s property to have their claims heard by a jury. In the case of Rodriguez vs. Del Sol Shopping Center Associates LLC, NM 2014(Docket Nos. 33,896 , 33,949) the Court reversed a lower court’s judgment that threw out the plaintiffs’ suit and instead sent the case back down to go to trial.

The Facts
In March of 2006, a woman who had previously been diagnosed with epilepsy had a seizure while driving her car in the parking lot of the defendant’s shopping center. The woman lost control of her vehicle and crashed through the window of a medical clinic, killing three people and seriously injuring several others. The injured parties and families of the deceased filed a New Mexico premises liability lawsuit against the shopping center, alleging that they failed to properly protect the patrons from the danger of a vehicle driving through the windows and that the failure resulted in the injuries and deaths.

A New Mexico Premises Liability Lawsuit
To be successful in a New Mexico premises liability lawsuit, a plaintiff must first show that the defendant owed them a duty. Second, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the defendant breached that duty, and third, the plaintiff must show that the defendant’s breach of that duty was the cause of an injury or damages. Generally, business owners owe their customers, or “invitees,” what is called a duty of ordinary care under the circumstances. The breadth of this duty varies with the facts of each case.

The Lower Court’s Decision
After the plaintiffs filed suit, the defendant filed a motion for the district court to rule in their favor, claiming that they did not owe the plaintiffs a duty in this situation. The defendant argued that the type of accident that occurred could not have been predicted and was in no way the responsibility of the shopping center. The district court agreed with the defendants and ruled that the shopping center did not have a duty to protect against criminally reckless drivers, so the accident “was not foreseeable as a matter of law,” and therefore no duty existed. This judgment was confirmed by the New Mexico Court of Appeals
On Appeal to the State Supreme Court
The plaintiffs appealed the decision to the New Mexico Supreme Court. They claimed that business owners always owe a duty of ordinary care under the circumstances to their customers, and that the foreseeability of any harm should not affect the existence of that duty. According to the plaintiffs’ argument, the foreseeability of the harm should be relevant only to the question of whether the defendants breached that duty. Because this question is a factual one, the plaintiffs argued that the issue should be decided by a jury and not dismissed “as a matter of law” by the court. The Supreme Court agreed, finding that the prior courts’ rulings were misguided and that “foreseeability is not a question for courts to consider when determining the existence of a duty, or whether to limit or eliminate an existing duty in a particular class of cases.” The Court reasoned that the question of whether the defendant was to be held financially responsible for the injuries was one to be answered by the jury, and the case would go to trial.

Have You Been Injured While on the Property of Another?

If you or someone you love has been injured or killed while on another’s property, this ruling helps ensure that a jury will be able to hear your side of the story. Even unexpected injuries can be prevented, and business owners almost always have some duty to protect their customers. Now, more than ever, it is important for accident victims to find competent legal counsel in premises liability cases. Although this ruling does not guarantee that any injury suffered on another’s property will be compensated, a skilled New Mexico accident attorney can help make the case for damages to a jury. If you have been injured, the attorneys at The Fine Law Firm are interested in your case. We try all kinds of New Mexico personal injury cases, including premises liability, and we have the skill that is needed to make the strongest arguments before the court and jury to pursue what you deserve. Call us today at (505)889-3463 or contact us through the website to schedule a free consultation.
More Blog Posts:

New Mexico Personal Injury Plaintiff has Suit Dismissed for Failure to Meet Witness Deadline, New Mexico Personal Injury Lawyer Blog, April 19, 2014.

New Mexico Federal Court Rejects Defendant’s Attempt to Disqualify Plaintiff’s Witness in Slip-and-Fall Case, New Mexico Personal Injury Lawyer Blog, April 5, 2014.

Request FREE
Consultation

Consent*

By submitting this form and signing up for texts, you consent to receive informational text messages regarding case details, and ask for the documents, including status updates and reminders for important dates or notifications, from Joseph M Fine PA at the number provided, including messages sent by an autodialer. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP. Reply HELP for help. Privacy Policy. Terms and Conditions.

* Required Fields
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent Posts

  • Fine Law Firm Requests Investigation Into Gustavo Gomez’s IAFD Tenure
  • Albuquerque’s Toxic Police Subculture
  • Filing an Amazon Accident Claim
  • Evidence You Need for Your E-Scooter Accident Claim
  • Do You Need Insurance Coverage to Ride an E-Scooter in New Mexico?

Categories

  • Aggressive Driving
  • Auto Accidents
  • Bicycle Accidents
  • Bike & Pedestrian Accidents
  • Brain Injury
  • Burn Injury
  • Bus Accidents
  • Car Accidents
  • Catastrophic Injury
  • Construction Accidents
  • Dog Bite
  • Drunk Driving
  • E-Scooter Accidents
  • Firm News
  • Government Liability
  • Insurance Companies
  • Legal Research
  • Legal Terminology
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • New Mexico Laws
  • Nursing Home Abuse
  • Oddities
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Personal Injury
  • Personal Injury FAQs
  • Personal Injury News
  • Personal Injury Verdicts
  • Police Brutality
  • Premises Liability
  • Product Liability
  • Relevant Personal Injury Case Law
  • Rideshare Accident
  • Slip & Fall
  • Spinal Injuries
  • Sporting Injuries
  • Traumatic Brain Injury
  • Truck Accidents
  • Uncategorized
  • Uninsured Motorist
  • Work Place Injury
  • Wrongful Death

Archives

  • 2025
  • 2024
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2008
  • 2007
Risk-free guarantee

Contact us for your free consultation

Risk-free guarantee

Contact us for your free consultation

Consent*

By submitting this form and signing up for texts, you consent to receive informational text messages regarding case details, and ask for the documents, including status updates and reminders for important dates or notifications, from Joseph M Fine PA at the number provided, including messages sent by an autodialer. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP. Reply HELP for help. Privacy Policy. Terms and Conditions.

* Required Fields
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Faqs
In selecting injury attorneys, the client should consider the following questions:

Do the attorneys have a history of winning cases like mine?

Do I trust the attorneys to act in my best interest rather than their own?

How do the attorneys’ fees compare with others?

View more faq’s
Fine Law Firm
Hablamos Español
Contact Us Hablamos español (505) 889-3463
Fax (505) 242-2716
Our Office Locations
Our Albuquerque Office
220 9th St NW
Albuquerque,
NM 87102
Get Directions

Copyright © 2025 by Fine Law Firm

  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy